A Kentucky employee secured an AI opt-out on Humanist grounds
David Durman does not believe in a god. He obtained a religious accommodation from personal AI use, and his university says he can still perform his essential duties.
A university employee has secured permission to do his job without personally using AI, citing sincerely held Humanist beliefs. David Durman, a University of Kentucky research administrator, is a nontheistic Humanist. His case puts a concrete workplace question behind the debate about AI adoption: what happens when an employee’s convictions conflict with using the technology?
In an October 29 report, TechCrunch interviewed Durman and the American Humanist Association and obtained a response from the university. The association had announced the case on October 26. According to that original statement, Durman requested an accommodation in late August, met with the university’s Office of Equal Opportunity in September and received approval on September 25. This is new reporting on an existing decision, not a new court ruling.
The university says the job can still be done
University spokesperson Jay Blanton told TechCrunch that requests are reviewed individually, taking account of job responsibilities and the circumstances. In Durman’s case, the university determined that an accommodation could be provided while he continued performing the essential functions of his position. It also said accommodations may be reviewed as technology and responsibilities evolve.
Durman supports researchers applying for grants. TechCrunch reports that he had not been required to use AI, although colleagues and leadership had encouraged employees to try it. He sought protection before a recommendation might become a requirement. The accommodation concerns his own use, rather than a ban on colleagues’ tools.
A belief-based objection, with individual boundaries
Durman told TechCrunch that active thinking and reasoning are central to becoming a moral actor. In the association’s statement, he also raised objections concerning employment, environmental costs and human creativity. Those are his stated convictions, rather than findings established by the accommodation.
The association’s attorney argues that comprehensive nontheistic belief systems such as Humanism qualify for religious protections alongside traditional religions. The case illustrates that argument in a specific workplace setting. It does not establish an automatic exemption for every employee who dislikes AI, or prove that the same arrangement would be workable in a different role.
For organizations encouraging AI use, the immediate tension is practical as well as philosophical: whether a particular employee can meet their responsibilities through an alternative way of working. The university’s reported answer in this case was yes, subject to review as the job changes.